Arkansas Freedom of Information Act requests to the City of Elkins about Stokenbury Farms, and the enforcement cases that followed in Washington County Circuit Court.
Status as of November 12, 2026. This page summarizes public filings and correspondence. It is not legal advice. The cases are pending, and this page will be updated.
Where Things Stand
- Three FOIA enforcement cases are pending in Washington County Circuit Court: 72CV-26-2120, 72CV-26-3999 and 72CV-26-4000, all arising from FOIA requests first submitted in April 2026.
- Next hearing: December 8, 2026, at 2:00 p.m. (all three cases). Pending in all three cases: the requester’s Motions to Compel (filed Sep 23) and the City’s requests that they be stricken (Oct 14 and Oct 16).
- After an August 31 hearing, the Court encouraged the parties to narrow the disputes. The requester submitted narrowed requests in all three cases on September 3.
- The central question in Case 2120 is whether the City’s search was complete. Records about the same property and subject matter were later produced in response to a separate June 2026 request.
Case 72CV-26-2120
Records concerning a residential property in Stokenbury Farms Phase 2: grading, drainage, engineering review, inspections, floodplain and permitting records, issuance of the Certificate of Occupancy, and related City communications.
Apr 2, 2026
FOIA request submitted to the City. The City acknowledges receipt and says processing will begin after the holiday closure.
Source: Request and City acknowledgment
Apr 7, 2026
The City produces records, including permits, certificates, plats, meeting minutes and subdivision records. The requester notes the response appears incomplete and asks for communications, complaints, engineering, drainage, floodplain and inspection records. The City provides correspondence about a drainage study and states that, to its knowledge, no other documentation specific to the property exists.
Source: City correspondence
Apr 8, 2026
The requester asks the City to clarify the scope of its search. The City states that records under both lot numbers associated with the property were searched and that no additional responsive records are known to exist.
Source: City correspondence
May 11, 2026
Petition for Enforcement of the Arkansas Freedom of Information Act filed. The City is served May 15.
Source: Court docket
Jun 11, 2026
The City files its Answer.
Source: Court docket
Jun 15, 2026
Amended Petition filed; served on the Mayor Jun 17.
Source: Amended Petition (file-stamped Jun 15, 2026)
Jul 6, 2026
The City files its Answer to the Amended Petition, admitting that the City Clerk is the custodian of public records and otherwise responding to the allegations.
Source: Answer to Amended Petition (file-stamped Jul 6, 2026)
Jul 7, 2026
In response to a separate June 24 request for construction stormwater and MS4 records, the City produces records and says more are being obtained from its engineering firm, Garver. That production later proves to include records about the same property, such as drainage reports, a FEMA record, permits and the Certificate of Occupancy.
Source: City production under the June 24 request
Aug 20–21, 2026
Motion to Set Matter for Hearing filed; the Court sets a hearing for Aug 31.
Source: Court docket
Aug 31, 2026
Hearing held. The Court encourages the parties to narrow and reduce the scope of the remaining disputes.
Source: Court record; later correspondence
Sep 3, 2026
The requester submits narrowed requests in all three cases, focused on the property, grading, drainage, engineering review, inspections, the Certificate of Occupancy and related communications. The City’s attorney acknowledges them the same day and says he will review them. A follow-up hearing is later set for Oct 28.
Source: Narrowed scope filings; email correspondence
Sep 21, 2026
The requester asks for a status update on the narrowed requests.
Source: Email correspondence
Sep 23, 2026
The requester files a Motion to Compel Response, Production, Identification of Search Efforts, and Sworn Search Affidavits. The motion states that about three weeks after the narrowed requests, no supplementation, objections or explanation of searches had been received. Where the City contends records do not exist, it asks for sworn affidavits describing who searched, what was searched and how.
Source: Motion to Compel (file-stamped Sep 23, 2026)
Oct 14, 2026
The City files its Response to the Motion to Compel. It admits some paragraphs and denies others, and argues that a motion to compel under Arkansas Rule of Civil Procedure 37 is limited to discovery matters and cannot be used to enforce a timeline the requester set. It asks the Court to strike or deny the motion and to award the City its costs and attorney’s fees.
Source: City’s Response to Motion to Compel (file-stamped Oct 14, 2026)
Oct 26, 2026
Two days before the scheduled hearing, the City sends the requester links to documents from Garver, a drawing and paperwork from 2008. City correspondence shows Garver had provided Stokenbury Phase 2 drainage records to the City on Jul 28 and retention pond redesign files on Sep 8.
Source: City email of Oct 26, 2026, with forwarded Garver correspondence
Oct 28, 2026
The scheduled hearing does not go forward because of a courthouse facility issue. The parties meet informally that day.
Source: Requester’s account
Dec 8, 2026
Hearing scheduled at 2:00 p.m. in all three cases.
Source: Court scheduling correspondence
Case 72CV-26-4000
Records on the 2016 Stokenbury Farms building moratorium: the conditions for lifting it, the required engineer certification, detention pond remediation, the City’s decision to let development resume, ownership of the pond lots, and the transfer of maintenance responsibility to the Property Owners Association. See the Moratorium Timeline for what the records show.
Jul 20, 2026
FOIA request submitted. Its stated purpose is to identify the records the City relied on in deciding the detention pond concerns behind the moratorium had been addressed, and the current ownership and maintenance responsibility for the ponds. The City acknowledges it the same day: “This will be added to your other requests. Please allow time to pull all records.”
Source: Request and City acknowledgment, Jul 20, 2026
Jul 22, 2026
The City’s attorney asks for additional time, explaining that City staff are searching, that most responsive records are expected to be in files of a staff member who is away, and that he will contact the engineers who worked with the City at the time. The requester agrees to additional time and rolling production.
Source: Correspondence, Jul 22, 2026
Aug 4, 2026
City staff tell the requester the information has been sent to the City Attorney for review, and that City staff have contacted Rausch Coleman about the POA responsibilities. City correspondence later produced to the requester shows that the same day, City staff sent the City Attorney the records gathered so far (retention pond files, a pond analysis, the Crafton Tull drainage report and the preliminary plat approval) “for review before we send to [the requester].”
Source: City email, Aug 4, 2026
Aug 18, 2026
The requester follows up, noting the request is nearly a month old and no responsive records have been received, and asks for a production timeline.
Source: Requester email, Aug 18, 2026
Aug 20, 2026
Petition for enforcement filed (Case 72CV-26-4000), one month after the request, with no records yet produced.
Source: Complaint (file-stamped Aug 20, 2026)
Aug 28, 2026
Eight days after the petition was filed, the City’s attorney emails the requester records he believed were responsive, saying he could not confirm whether they had been sent before and apologizing for the mix-up. They include the detention pond analysis, pond remediation and engineering review records, the 2019 planning approval, and drainage and floodplain review records. The same day, the City files its Answer. It admits several paragraphs, says the cited records and exhibits speak for themselves, and denies that the requester has stated a cause of action or is entitled to relief under the FOIA.
Source: City attorney email, Aug 28, 2026; City’s Answer (file-stamped Aug 28, 2026)
Sep 3, 2026
Narrowed request submitted, as in the other two cases. Set for hearing Dec 8, 2026.
Source: Narrowed scope filings; scheduling correspondence
Sep 23, 2026
Motion to Compel filed, matching the motion in Case 2120: about three weeks after the narrowed request, no supplementation, objections or explanation of searches had been received, so the motion asks for sworn affidavits describing the City’s search.
Source: Motion to Compel (file-stamped Sep 23, 2026)
Oct 16, 2026
The City files a Response matching its Case 2120 response: it argues the motion is improper under Rule 37, asks that it be stricken under Rule 12(f), and asks for its costs and attorney’s fees.
Source: City’s Response to Motion to Compel (file-stamped Oct 16, 2026)
Oct 26, 2026
Two days before the scheduled Oct 28 hearing, the City emails the requester more records, including Garver correspondence and links, a drawing, 2008 paperwork on the detention ponds, and City FOIA correspondence from July to September.
Source: City email, Oct 26, 2026
Case 72CV-26-3999
Records on construction stormwater management at Stokenbury Farms and the construction site next to Dollar General on N Center St: erosion and sediment control, inspections, monitoring, SWPPP and BMP records, MS4 activities, compliance and enforcement, photographs, videos and related communications. See the Stormwater Compliance Chronology for what the Arkansas DEQ records show.
The central question: whether the City’s search was complete. On July 7 the City said it was still waiting on more records from its engineering consultant, Garver. On August 21 the City said its search was complete, while also saying Garver was still searching its own records.
Jun 24, 2026
FOIA request submitted for construction stormwater and MS4 records. The request expressly includes records kept on personal devices and accounts used for public business.
Source: Complaint, Exhibit A
Jun 30, 2026
After no acknowledgment, the requester follows up. The Mayor acknowledges the request the same day and says the City expects to produce records by July 10.
Source: Complaint, Exhibits B and C
Jul 7, 2026
The City produces records: permits, drainage reports and a drainage deviation report, floodplain and FEMA records, plats, planning and council minutes, a 2019 rezoning ordinance, emails with Garver and Crafton Tull, a SWPPP-related email, a construction stormwater permit, and two violation videos and violation photographs. The City writes that it is “still waiting on a few more things from Garver” and will send them when received.
Source: Complaint, Exhibit D
Jul 12, 2026
The requester asks whether inspection, monitoring, compliance, SWPPP, BMP, enforcement and MS4 records, photos, videos, attachments and complete email chains were searched for, because few of those categories appear in the production.
Source: Complaint, Exhibit E
Jul 20, 2026
The requester follows up. City staff reply that the official with that information is out on vacation. The requester agrees to wait and asks for rolling production of anything already available, including records received from Garver.
Source: Complaint, Exhibits F, G and H
Aug 3–4, 2026
The requester sends a detailed second follow-up asking which custodians, repositories and consultant records were searched, and the next day writes to the City Attorney for clarification.
Source: Complaint, Exhibits I and J
Aug 20, 2026
The requester files this FOIA enforcement action. It asks the Court to determine whether the City complied with the FOIA, order production of non-exempt records, identify anything withheld and the legal basis, and require a sworn affidavit describing the search. Complaint with exhibits (file-stamped Aug 20, 2026)
Aug 21, 2026
The day after filing, the City answers the open questions. It states that its search is complete, that a Garver representative is conducting additional searches of Garver’s records, that responsive records were located across the requested categories, that all responsive records have been produced, and that nothing has been withheld. City’s August 21 response
Aug 28, 2026
The City files its Answer, denying that it failed to comply and asking that the case be dismissed with costs and attorney’s fees. City’s Answer (file-stamped Aug 28, 2026)
Aug 31 – Sep 3, 2026
After the August 31 hearing, the Court encourages the parties to narrow the dispute. On September 3 the requester sends narrowed requests, and the City Attorney replies that he will “review and begin working on determining what additional, responsive documents there are and gathering them.” City Attorney’s Sep 3 acknowledgment
Sep 21–23, 2026
The requester asks for a status update on September 21. On September 23 he files a Motion to Compel asking for supplemental production or, where the City says records do not exist, sworn affidavits identifying who searched, what was searched and how. The motion acknowledges the Court cannot compel production of records that do not exist. Motion to Compel (file-stamped Sep 23, 2026)
Oct 16, 2026
The City responds that a motion to compel under Rule 37 is limited to discovery, that the motion is improper and should be stricken under Rule 12(f), and asks the Court to consider awarding attorney’s fees against the requester. City’s Response to Motion to Compel (file-stamped Oct 16, 2026)
Dec 8, 2026
Hearing set for 2:00 p.m. in all three cases.
Related Requests
- Stormwater Compliance Chronology: includes the June 24, 2026 construction stormwater and MS4 request and the City’s production.
- Moratorium Timeline: records on the Stokenbury Farms detention ponds.
Court filings and correspondence will be linked here, with personal contact information redacted.