Elkins AR Building Moratorium: Stokenbury Farms Timeline

What City of Elkins and Washington County records show about the Stokenbury Farms detention ponds, from the City engineer’s 2008 report through the 2016 building moratorium to 2026.

This timeline is compiled from records produced by the City of Elkins in response to Arkansas FOIA requests and from documents recorded with the Washington County Circuit Clerk. Every entry cites the exhibit and page it comes from. Quotes are copied from the documents. This is a summary of the paper record. It is not legal or engineering advice.

Infographic: Stokenbury Ponds, how liability for the detention ponds shifted to homeowners
Infographic by C. King (text corrected for accuracy, Nov 2026)

📄 Download the full records packet (PDF, 199 pages). Every “Ex.” citation on this page links to the exact page in the packet.

The Short Version

  1. The ponds have been a known problem since at least 2008. The City’s own engineer reported in 2008 that the ponds were too flat to drain. In 2016 the City stopped issuing building permits over them until 2018. Source: Ex. A, p. 1
  2. 2018: the developer’s repair duty was written to end when the POA took the ponds. The developer agreed to fix the ponds within 120 days, but only “until” a property owners association (POA) was established, funded and given title. Source: Ex. A, p. 4
  3. The POA got the ponds before the repairs were due. The pond deed was signed Mar 15, 2018, before the POA existed, and recorded Jul 27, 2018, before the 120-day deadline. No record shows the 2018 repairs were completed or inspected. Source: Ex. B, pp. 1-2; Ex. C, p. 1
  4. The POA started with almost no money and was run by the developer. $0 initial assessment, $100/yr dues, developer exempt from dues. The developer appointed the board and had 4 votes per lot. Source: Ex. C, pp. 2-4
  5. 2021: Phase 2 was bonded for six months, and the pond problem was already on the list. $189,658 bond. Item 18 (pipe flow line below pond bottom) was still open in 2023. Source: Ex. E, p. 1; Ex. D, p. 9; Ex. F, p. 7
  6. Feb 2024: the Mayor set the standard: “fixed correctly once and for all.” He wrote that he was “not okay with it works better now than it did.” Source: Ex. I, p. 1
  7. Nov 2024: the work was accepted on “much improved to the best of the developer’s ability.” The City’s engineering firm, Garver, had asked for confirmation it “will no longer hold water.” It got “much improved” and accepted it. No City official’s acceptance or bond release letter appears in the records. Source: Ex. K, p. 1; Ex. M, pp. 1, 3
  8. The cost now falls on homeowners. The covenants make the POA repair and maintain the ponds, and say owners release the developer from pond claims. More pond lots (Phase III, Lots A & C) were deeded to the POA in May 2026. Source: Ex. C, pp. 6-7; Ex. N, p. 1

Bottom line: on paper, the ponds were handed to the homeowners before anyone documented that they were fixed. Any remaining repair costs fall on the POA, meaning the homeowners, through dues or special assessments.


Timeline

Apr 8, 2008

The City’s engineer, Jorgensen & Associates, reports to the City on an as-built survey of the Stokenbury Farms detention ponds. The north pond slopes at 0.05% and the south pond at 0.17%, while “generally you should have at least 0.50% grade for water to flow.” The letter says “there are no good solutions to this problem” and offers two options: regrade the pond bottoms into retention ponds (preliminary estimate $47,668), or regrade and add pumps ($67,668).
Source: Jorgensen & Associates letter to the City of Elkins, Apr 8, 2008 (produced by the City under the Arkansas FOIA)

Nov 2016

The City places a moratorium on building permits in Stokenbury Farms because the detention ponds are not draining. Re-issued Dec 2017 and Mar 2018.
Source: Ex. A, pp. 1, 3

Sep 20, 2017

The developer’s engineer (Crafton Tull) analyzes the ponds. It finds them “completely flat” with low spots, and one outlet “laid below the flowline of the creek.” It says the original construction “cannot be completely corrected without a major re-work and re-design,” but certifies that once regraded with a new outlet the ponds “will function properly.”
Source: Ex. A, pp. 14-15

Mar 15, 2018

Fresh Start Properties, LLC signs a quitclaim deed for pond Lots 139 & 140 to the Stokenbury Farms POA. This is before the POA was created on Apr 25. The legal description reads “52.94 acres.”
Source: Ex. B, pp. 1-2

Apr 19, 2018

The City lifts the moratorium. NWA LD, LLC agrees to dredge and regrade the ponds and replace the outlet within 120 days so they “shall adequately drain storm water.” The duty runs only “until such time as the Property Owners Association shall be established, funded and the title to the Detention Ponds has been transferred.” The developer’s signature line is blank on this copy.
Source: Ex. A, pp. 1, 3-5

Apr 23-25, 2018

Covenants are recorded, creating the POA “to maintain the servicing detention ponds.” The ponds (Lots 139 & 140) become Common Property. The developer appoints the board and has 4 votes per lot. $0 initial assessment, $100/yr dues, developer exempt. Owners “waive, release and hold harmless” the developer on pond claims. The POA must repair and maintain.
Source: Ex. C, pp. 1-4, 6 (Sec. 5), 7 (Sec. 7)

Jul 27, 2018

The pond deed is recorded, about three weeks before the 120-day repair deadline.
Source: Ex. B, p. 1

Oct 18, 2021

The Phase 2 final plat is approved before the work is finished, conditioned on a six-month performance bond. If the work is not completed, “no additional building permits shall be issued within this phase or future phases.” A 30-month maintenance bond is also required. Punch list item 18: “Existing pipe flow line appears to be lower than the pond bottom.”
Source: Ex. D, pp. 1, 9 (item 18), 10

Nov 5, 2021

A $189,658 performance bond is issued (RLI No. CMS0346671; principal NWA LD, LLC).
Source: Ex. E, p. 1

May 18, 2023

Second bond inspection, item 18: “Trickle channel added, but standing water is present on either side of this. Grade to be corrected.”
Source: Ex. F, p. 7

Nov 7, 2023

Walkthrough: north pond water “is not adequately draining and causing damage to the pipes under the road” (item 1). Item 10: “Ensure that ground is level and won’t hold water at the trickle channel.”
Source: Ex. G, pp. 1, 2, 8

Dec 13, 2023

The developer’s engineer finds the outlet headwall apron was “constructed too high.”
Source: Ex. H, p. 1

Feb 2024

The developer’s engineer says the old pond “was not maintained.” Under the 2018 agreement, maintenance was the developer’s job until the POA took over.
Source: Ex. M, p. 20

Feb 20, 2024

Mayor Reed and City staff inspect and find “three inches of water standing in the channel.” The Mayor writes: “I would like that to be fixed correctly once and for all. I am not okay with it works better now than it did.” This email went only to Garver and City staff.
Source: Ex. I, p. 1

Mar 26, 2024

Garver’s engineer: “we do not feel that it would take much effort to fix the issue in this area, there is plenty of fall to grade the area to drain.”
Source: Ex. M, p. 17; Ex. L, p. 1

Oct 8, 2024

The developer says the area was regraded and “Vegetation is now growing good,” and asks for the bond release. The attached photo shows water standing in the channel.
Source: Ex. J, pp. 1, 14 (photo)

Nov 3, 2024

Garver asks the developer whether its engineer can confirm “this will no longer hold water.”
Source: Ex. K, p. 1; Ex. M, p. 9

Nov 4, 2024

The developer’s engineer: “I can certify the grading and stabilization is complete the previous pond has been much improved to the best of the developer’s ability.” This is not a statement that it no longer holds water.
Source: Ex. M, p. 3

Nov 5, 2024

Garver: “…we agree this is acceptable.”
Source: Ex. M, p. 1

May 26-27, 2026

NWA LD, LLC deeds Phase III pond and drainage Lots A & C to the POA.
Source: Ex. N, pp. 1, 6 (plat sheet 4)

Nov 6, 2026

Garver forwards these emails internally, three days after a Nov 3, 2026 FOIA request. Source: message metadata.
Source: Ex. H, p. 1; Ex. M, p. 1


Records Referenced but Not Found

These records are referred to in the documents, or would be expected, but were not in what the City produced.


Exhibits

📄 Download the full records packet (PDF, 199 pages). Every “Ex.” citation on this page links to the exact page in the packet.

Have records, photos or first-hand information about the Stokenbury Farms ponds? Contact us.